What Not to Say to Insurance Adjusters After a Car Accident

by: 
 | February 18, 2025
What not to say to insurance adjusters after a car accident

After a car accident, dealing with insurance adjusters can be tricky. They may seem friendly, but their job is to protect the insurance company, not you. What you say to them can affect your personal injury claim. Even small statements can hurt your chances of getting maximum compensation.

BAM Personal Injury Lawyers helps you understand what to say (and what not to say) when speaking to an insurance company after a car crash. Our experienced car accident attorneys will guide you through the claims process, making sure your rights are protected. We know how insurance adjusters operate and can help you avoid common mistakes that could hurt your case.

Looking for an Idago Car Accident Lawyer? Contact BAM Personal Injury Lawyers

Contact My Car Accident Lawyer Now

“I’m Sorry” or Admitting Fault

After an accident, it's natural to feel bad for others involved, but saying "I’m sorry" or admitting fault can harm your personal injury claim. These statements may be used against you, even if you’re not at fault. It’s best to stay cautious and avoid saying anything that may hurt your case.

Why This is a Mistake

Admitting fault or apologizing can have serious consequences for your car accident claim. Insurance adjusters may use these statements to argue that you were responsible for the accident, even if it wasn’t entirely your fault. Once you admit fault, it becomes harder to claim compensation for medical bills, property damage, or pain and suffering.

Even if you feel sympathy for others involved in the accident, remember that your words can be twisted to minimize the value of your claim. Always let the investigation determine who is at fault. Saying “I’m sorry” might appear as an admission of guilt and negatively affect the outcome of your case.

What to Say Instead

Instead of saying “I’m sorry” or admitting fault, keep your response neutral. You can say:

  • “I’m not sure what happened; I need to see the details.”
    This avoids claiming responsibility and leaves room for the investigation.
  • “I’m glad no one is seriously injured.”
    This shows concern without admitting fault.
  • “I prefer to discuss the accident after I have more information.”
    This allows you to gather the facts before making any statements about liability.“I’m Not Injured” or Downplaying Your Injuries.

After an accident, you may feel okay or be in shock, and you might say “I’m not injured.” Even if you think you’re fine, it's essential not to downplay any pain or injuries. Some injuries, like whiplash or internal damage, may not show symptoms immediately.

Why This is a Mistake

Downplaying your injuries can hurt your car accident case. Even if you feel fine in the moment, injuries like neck pain, headaches, or back pain can get worse over time. Saying you're not injured right away may make it difficult to prove the extent of your injuries later on.

Insurance adjusters will use any statement you make about being "fine" to limit your claim. They might argue that since you didn’t report injuries immediately, they are not serious or related to the accident. Get checked by a doctor, even if you don’t feel pain right away, to protect your claim.

What to Say Instead

If you’re unsure about your condition, say, “I’m still shaken up and need to see a doctor to assess any injuries fully.” This shows you are taking the situation seriously and seeking proper medical attention. Even if you feel fine, a doctor’s evaluation can help prevent the insurance company from minimizing your injuries.

Giving a Recorded Statement

After a car accident, the insurance adjuster may ask you for a recorded statement. While this might seem like a simple request, be cautious. The information you provide can be used against you later in the claims process.

Why This is a Mistake

Giving a recorded statement to an insurance adjuster can be risky. Even though the adjuster may sound friendly, they work for the insurance company, which aims to reduce the amount they pay out. Any information you provide, even unintentionally, can be used to lower your settlement or deny your claim.

Recorded statements can sometimes be taken out of context, making you appear inconsistent or unclear about the details of the accident. If you say anything that contradicts your initial report or doesn't fit with the medical evidence, the insurance company can use it to weaken your case. It's better to let your personal injury lawyer handle any communication with the insurance company.

What to Say Instead

  • “I will speak to my attorney first.”
    Let the adjuster know that you would like to consult with your lawyer before providing a statement.
  • “I prefer to provide a statement in writing.”
    Request to give your statement in writing, where you can carefully consider what to say.
  • “I’m not sure; I’ll get back to you after I speak with my lawyer.”
    This gives you time to gather your thoughts and seek legal advice before making any statements.

Speculating About What Happened

Speculating about what happened

When speaking with an insurance adjuster, you might be asked about the details of the accident. While it’s natural to want to explain what happened, it’s important not to speculate. Any uncertainty in your statement can affect your claim.

Why This is a Mistake

Speculating about the cause of the accident or the details of what happened can hurt your case. Insurance adjusters are trained to look for inconsistencies or doubts. If you make an educated guess or say something you’re unsure about, it could weaken your claim.

Speculation may lead the insurance company to argue that you don’t have clear evidence or a reliable recollection of the incident. This can reduce the value of your claim or even lead to a denial. It’s essential to stick to the facts and avoid guessing about any part of the accident. Let your lawyer handle any uncertainties during the claims process.

What to Say Instead

  • “I don’t know for sure, but I can provide the details I remember.”
    This shows you’re only sharing what you know and are being honest about your recollection.
  • “I’ll refer to the police report for the facts.”
    Relying on the official report ensures your statement is based on documented facts.
  • “I’ll discuss the details with my attorney before I comment further.”
    This keeps you from making any speculative statements and protects your case.

Giving Too Much Information About Your Medical History

When discussing your injuries with an insurance adjuster, stick to the details relevant to the car accident. Avoid sharing too much information about your entire medical history. The insurance company may try to use unrelated past medical issues against you.

Why This is a Mistake

Providing too much information about your medical history can open the door for the insurance company to attack your claim. If you mention previous injuries or conditions that are unrelated to the accident, they may argue that your current injuries are pre-existing or not caused by the crash.

Insurance adjusters may use your past medical history to downplay your current injury or deny compensation. Sharing irrelevant information can create confusion and harm your claim, even if your past health is unrelated to the accident. It's best to keep the focus on the injuries you suffered directly from the accident.

What to Say Instead

  • “I will only discuss the injuries caused by this accident.”
    This keeps the conversation focused on your current injuries and avoids unrelated topics.
  • “I’ll provide details of my treatment related to the accident only.”
    Stick to the treatment you’ve received for injuries directly tied to the car accident.
  • “Please speak with my lawyer for any additional questions.”
    This directs the adjuster to your attorney, avoiding unnecessary details.

Accepting a Quick Settlement Offer

Accepting a quick settlement offer

After a car accident, the insurance company may offer you a quick settlement. It might seem tempting to accept the offer and get the process over with. However, this can often be a mistake.

Why This is a Mistake

Accepting a quick settlement offer can mean accepting much less than you deserve. Insurance companies often offer a low amount to settle quickly and avoid a lengthy claims process. These offers typically don’t account for all your medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering.

Once you accept the settlement, you can’t go back and ask for more money. Your injuries might also worsen over time, which means the quick settlement might not cover future medical expenses. Consult with a skilled lawyer before accepting any offer to ensure you’re getting fair compensation.

What to Say Instead

  • “I need time to think about this offer.”
    This gives you space to evaluate the offer and consult your lawyer.
  • “I’ll discuss this with my lawyer before making a decision.”
    This ensures you’re making an informed decision with professional guidance.
  • “I’ll wait until my injuries are fully assessed before accepting any offer.”
    This ensures that the settlement covers all medical costs, including future treatment.

Saying, “I Don’t Have a Lawyer” (Even If You Don’t Yet)

After an accident, an insurance adjuster might ask if you have a lawyer. Even if you haven’t hired one yet, it's vital not to say that you don’t have one.

Why This is a Mistake

Saying that you don’t have a lawyer can make you vulnerable to pressure from the insurance company. Adjusters may take advantage of your situation and push you into accepting a low settlement. They may also try to get you to sign paperwork or make statements that aren’t in your best interest.

Having a lawyer gives you protection during the claims process. Even if you haven't hired one yet, you can always say that you are considering getting legal representation. This will prevent the adjuster from taking advantage of you.

What to Say Instead

  • “I’m considering hiring an attorney to represent me.”
    This keeps the conversation open without giving the adjuster any advantage.
  • “I’ll talk to my lawyer before moving forward with anything.”
    This ensures you’re not pressured into making quick decisions without professional guidance.
  • “I’m gathering information before deciding on legal representation.”
    This gives you the time to think and explore your options before making a choice.

FAQs

Should I talk to an insurance claims adjuster without a lawyer?

It’s not advisable to speak with an insurance claims adjuster without consulting a car accident lawyer first. They may try to get you to say something that can hurt your claim. An experienced lawyer can guide you on what to say to an insurance company to protect your rights.

How can medical records affect my insurance claim?

Medical records are crucial in proving the extent of your injuries. They provide evidence of the treatment you’ve received and link your injuries to the car accident. Without proper medical records, it may be difficult to get a fair settlement.

Can I file an insurance claim with my own insurance company?

Yes, you can file an insurance claim with your own insurance company, even if the accident wasn’t your fault. Your insurance company may cover medical bills and other expenses until the at-fault party’s insurance is determined.

What should I say to an insurance company after a car accident?

Keep your communication with the insurance company simple and factual. Avoid speculating about the accident or providing unnecessary details. It’s best to consult with a personal injury attorney before talking to the insurance adjuster.

Do I need a personal injury attorney after a car accident?

While it’s not required, hiring a personal injury attorney can help you get the compensation you deserve. They can deal with the insurance claims adjuster, ensure your medical records are properly submitted, and help you through the claims process.

Looking for an Idago Car Accident Lawyer? Contact BAM Personal Injury Lawyers

call 801-839-5652

Contact Our Idaho Car Accident Lawyer for a Free Consultation

Contact our Idaho car accident lawyer for a free consultation

If you’ve been injured in a car accident, BAM Personal Injury Lawyers is here to help. We know the challenges accident victims face after a crash, and we’re dedicated to ensuring that you receive fair compensation for your injuries, medical bills, and lost wages.

Our experienced car accident lawyers will guide you through the claims process, working with insurance companies and fighting for your rights. We will handle all the legal details so you can focus on your recovery. Contact us today for a free consultation. Let us help you get the justice and compensation you deserve.

BAM Personal Injury Lawyers - St. George, UT Office BAM Personal Injury Lawyers - Murray, UT Office BAM Personal Injury Lawyers - Meridian, ID Office
KIGAN Martineau
PERSONAL INJURY LAWYER

Kigan Martineau, a seasoned Partner at BAM Injury Law, is a champion for those injured in vehicular mishaps, including car, eScooter, and bicycle accidents. His legal journey is marked by notable victories against major trucking companies like Matheson, UPS, and Swift Transportation, where his strategic litigation has resulted in significant client settlements. 

Notably, Kigan secured the highest settlement in Southern Utah, a record-setting figure that underscores his prowess in the courtroom. His deep-rooted commitment to his clients and his skill in personal injury law have helped recover over $100 million in resolutions, affirming his position as a leader in Southern Utah’s legal landscape.
Schedule Your
Free Consultation
Fill out the form

"*" indicates required fields

Full Name*
Required Fields *
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
chevron-down