What Is the Average Settlement for An Idaho Personal Injury Case?

by: 
 | April 22, 2025
What Is the Average Settlement for An Idaho Personal Injury Case?

If you’ve been hurt because of someone else’s actions, you may be wondering how much your case is worth. After all, medical bills add up fast, and missing work can put extra pressure on your finances. While every personal injury case is different, there are patterns in settlement amounts depending on the details of the incident.

BAM Personal Injury Lawyers helps injured victims in Idaho recover fair compensation. Whether you were in a car accident, suffered a fall, or experienced another type of injury, our legal team knows what it takes to pursue the maximum settlement possible. We take the time to look at your injuries, the repercussions on your life, and the insurance coverage available so we can fight for what you truly deserve.

There’s No Single “Average” Settlement Amount

Many people want a quick answer about what the average personal injury settlement looks like, but there is no one-size-fits-all amount. Every case involves different injuries, facts, and financial losses, so the final amount depends on those details.

Some injury settlement amounts may be just a few thousand dollars, while others reach into the hundreds of thousands. A fair settlement should reflect how badly you were hurt, how much your medical expenses cost, and how the injury has affected your life now and in the future.

Settlement Ranges Vary Based on Injury Severity

The severity of your injuries is one of the biggest factors in determining how much you might receive. Minor injuries that heal quickly usually result in lower settlements. On the other hand, cases involving severe injuries, like broken bones, nerve damage, or permanent disabilities, often lead to much larger payouts.

The more serious the injury, the higher your medical bills, the more time you may miss from work, and the longer your recovery may take. These details will all increase the value of your personal injury settlement. That’s why documentation of injuries sustained is so essential when seeking compensation.

Wrongful Death and Catastrophic Injury Claims

In cases involving wrongful death or catastrophic harm, such as traumatic brain injuries or paralysis, settlement amounts tend to be much higher. These cases often result in compensation of $500,000 or more, depending on the situation and insurance coverage involved.

Catastrophic injuries typically require lifelong care, ongoing medical treatment, and significant changes in a person’s ability to work or live independently. Families affected by a wrongful death may also be compensated for lost income, funeral costs, and emotional suffering.

These cases are more complex and often take longer to settle. Having a qualified personal injury attorney helps ensure the settlement properly reflects the lasting effects of the harm done.

Factors That Affect Settlement Amounts in Idaho

Factors That Affect Settlement Amounts in Idaho

Several key factors determine how much a personal injury case may settle for in Idaho. Understanding these can help you better estimate the value of your injury settlement.

Severity and Type of Injury

More serious injuries usually mean higher medical expenses, longer recovery times, and more disruption to your daily life. For example, a sprained ankle and a spinal cord injury will lead to very different settlement ranges.

The type of injury also matters. Some injuries, like brain trauma or internal organ damage, may not be visible but still have long-term effects. The more lasting and life-changing your injury is, the higher your personal injury settlement is likely to be.

Total Medical Costs and Future Treatment Needs

When calculating your injury settlement, insurance companies consider both past and future medical expenses. This includes hospital bills, surgery, medication, physical therapy, and any care you may need moving forward.

If you need ongoing treatment or follow-up procedures, your settlement should cover those as well. That’s why it’s best to wait until you reach maximum medical improvement before settling your case. This ensures that all your medical bills — both now and later — are included.

Lost Wages and Impact on Future Earning Ability

If you had to miss work because of your injuries, you may be able to recover lost wages in your settlement. The more time you miss, the more that part of your claim is worth. If your injury prevents you from returning to your previous job or working at all in the future, that loss is even greater.

An accomplished lawyer can help calculate the full impact your injury has had on your ability to earn and include that in the demand for compensation.

Pain and Suffering

Pain and suffering include both physical pain and emotional distress caused by the injury. This part of the settlement is harder to measure, but it’s just as important as medical expenses and lost income.

Your legal team will consider how the injury has affected your sleep, mental health, relationships, and ability to enjoy life. This is especially true in cases involving permanent scarring, disfigurement, or long-lasting trauma.

Degree of Fault

Idaho follows a modified comparative fault rule. This means if you are partially at fault for the accident, your compensation will be reduced based on your share of fault.

For example, if you’re found to be 20% responsible for the accident, your injury settlement will be reduced by 20%. If you are more than 50% at fault, you cannot recover any compensation. This makes proving the other party’s fault a key part of the case.

Insurance Policy Limits

Even if your case is worth a lot of money, the insurance company can only pay up to the policy limits. These limits can vary depending on whether you are dealing with a car accident, homeowner’s insurance, or business liability coverage.

If the value of your personal injury settlement exceeds those limits, your attorney may look for other options, such as suing multiple parties or checking for umbrella policies. A qualified personal injury attorney can help identify every source of available insurance coverage to maximize your compensation.

Idaho’s Modified Comparative Fault Rule

Idaho uses a modified comparative fault system. This means your role in the accident can directly affect your personal injury settlement. If you're partly at fault, the amount you receive will be reduced. If you're mostly at fault, you may get nothing at all.

How It Affects Your Settlement

Under this rule, if you are 50% or more at fault, you cannot recover any damages. But if you are 49% or less at fault, you can still recover compensation, though it will be reduced based on your level of fault.

For example, if your injury settlement is $100,000 and you’re found to be 25% responsible for the accident, you would receive $75,000. Insurance companies often try to increase your share of fault to pay less, which is why having legal representation is indispensable.

Example Calculation Based on Fault

Let’s say you were injured in a car crash, and your total damages (including medical expenses, lost income, and pain and suffering) add up to $200,000. If the insurance company determines you were 30% at fault, you would only receive 70% of the value.

That would reduce your injury settlement to $140,000. This kind of calculation is used in most personal injury cases in Idaho. The percentage of fault assigned can have a big impact on your final payment. A qualified personal injury attorney can challenge unfair fault claims and help protect your right to fair compensation.

Types of Damages You Can Recover in Idaho

Types of Damages You Can Recover in Idaho

When you file a personal injury lawsuit in Idaho, you may be able to recover different types of damages. These are usually split into three main categories: economic, non-economic, and punitive.

Economic Damages

Economic damages cover financial losses. This includes your medical expenses, lost wages, and other out-of-pocket costs related to the injury. These damages are easier to calculate because they are based on actual numbers.

You may also include future medical bills and lost future earnings, especially if your injury caused long-term problems. Keep all records, receipts, and invoices. This documentation will help your legal team build a strong claim and request a reasonable settlement.

Non-Economic Damages

Non-economic damages focus on how the injury has affected your life. These include pain and suffering, emotional distress, loss of enjoyment of life, and damage to personal relationships. These losses don’t have a set dollar value, but they are very real.

A fair settlement should consider how the injury has changed your daily routine and overall happiness. The more severe the injury, the more non-economic damages you may be able to recover.

Punitive Damages

Punitive damages are less common but may apply in cases where the other party acted with extreme negligence or intentional harm. These are meant to punish the wrongdoer and discourage similar behavior in the future.

For example, if someone caused a car accident while driving drunk or purposely harmed you, the court may award punitive damages. A seasoned lawyer can help determine if your case qualifies.

How Long It Takes to Settle a Personal Injury Claim in Idaho

Every personal injury case moves at its own pace. The timeline depends on many factors.

Timeline for Minor Injury Cases

If your injuries are minor and liability is clear, your case may settle within a few months. These types of cases are often resolved after your medical treatment ends. Once your medical expenses are calculated, your legal team can begin settlement negotiations.

Even in simple cases, delays can happen. Insurance companies may request more documents or try to undervalue your claim. Having a personal injury attorney can help keep the process moving.

Timeline for Complex or High-Value Cases

Cases involving severe injuries, large medical bills, or multiple parties usually take longer. These cases may take one year or more to resolve. More time is needed to investigate, gather evidence, and understand the full implications of the injury.

If the case involves traumatic brain injuries, permanent disabilities, or wrongful death, the timeline increases. Insurance companies often fight harder to avoid large payouts. Your attorney will work to build a strong case before beginning serious settlement discussions.

Role of Medical Treatment and Maximum Medical Improvement (MMI)

Your case should not be settled until you reach maximum medical improvement. This means your doctors believe your condition has stabilized and you will not improve further. At that point, your legal team can determine the full value of your injury settlement.

Settling too early could leave you without enough money for future medical care. That is why medical treatment and recovery time play a big role in how long your case lasts.

When to Hire an Idaho Personal Injury Lawyer

When to Hire an Idaho Personal Injury Lawyer

Not every case needs a lawyer, but many do. If the injuries are serious or the insurance company denies your claim, hiring an attorney can help protect your rights.

Insurance Company Denies or Undervalues Your Claim

Insurance companies often try to pay less than what your claim is worth. If they deny your claim or make a low offer, it is a good idea to speak with an attorney. A lawyer can help you gather the right evidence, challenge the decision, and fight for fair compensation.

You Suffered Serious or Long-Term Injuries

If you suffered broken bones, head trauma, or other severe injuries, your case will be more complex. You may need future treatment or long-term care. A personal injury attorney can calculate those costs and include them in your settlement demand. Without legal help, you may settle for less than what you actually need.

You’re Being Blamed for the Accident

If the other party or insurance company says you caused the accident, your ability to recover compensation could be affected. In Idaho, being more than 50 percent at fault means you cannot receive any money. A qualified personal injury attorney can investigate the case and push back against unfair blame.

A Lawyer Can Accurately Value and Maximize Your Settlement

A reliable lawyer will look at every part of your case, including medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering. They can help calculate a fair settlement and present a strong case to the insurance company.

If settlement negotiations fail, your lawyer can prepare to take the case to court. Having legal representation from the start helps protect your claim and increases your chances of receiving full compensation.

FAQs

How much is the average settlement for car accident cases in Idaho?

The average settlement varies widely. Minor car accident cases may settle for a few thousand dollars. More serious cases involving hospital stays or surgery can lead to higher settlements. The exact amount depends on the injuries, medical bills, and how much the injury affects your life.

When should I contact a car accident attorney?

You should contact a car accident attorney as soon as possible, especially if you suffered a car accident injury or if your claim was denied. An attorney can deal with the insurance company, gather evidence, and help protect your rights under personal injury law. Early help can make a big difference in the final result.

What does a personal injury lawyer do in car accident claims?

A lawyer can investigate the crash, collect medical records, calculate damages, and deal with the insurer. In car accident claims, they also work to prove the other driver’s fault. The goal is to build a strong case and pursue maximum compensation for your injuries and losses.

Can I still recover damages if I was partly at fault for the accident?

Yes. Idaho uses modified comparative fault. As long as you are less than 50 percent at fault, you can still recover damages. However, your settlement will be reduced based on your share of the blame.

Do all personal injury cases go to court?

No. Most cases settle out of court through negotiation. Your attorney will try to reach a fair settlement first. If the insurance company refuses to offer a reasonable amount, your legal team may take the case to trial.

Contact Our Idaho Personal Injury Attorney Today

Contact Our Idaho Personal Injury Attorney Today

If you were hurt in an accident, you should not have to deal with insurance companies or legal questions on your own. Your focus should be on healing. Let us handle the rest.

BAM Personal Injury Lawyers helps people across Idaho recover what they’re owed after a car accident, slip and fall, or other personal injury event. Whether you suffered a minor injury or are facing long-term care, our legal team will fight to secure the maximum compensation available under the law.

We understand how personal injury law works in Idaho. We know how to prove fault, calculate damages, and negotiate fair settlements. If needed, we’re prepared to take your case to court.

The consultation is free. You pay nothing unless we win your case. Call us today to speak with an experienced Idaho personal injury attorney about your rights and next steps.

BAM Personal Injury Lawyers - St. George, UT Office BAM Personal Injury Lawyers - Murray, UT Office BAM Personal Injury Lawyers - Meridian, ID Office
KIGAN Martineau
PERSONAL INJURY LAWYER

Kigan Martineau, a seasoned Partner at BAM Injury Law, is a champion for those injured in vehicular mishaps, including car, eScooter, and bicycle accidents. His legal journey is marked by notable victories against major trucking companies like Matheson, UPS, and Swift Transportation, where his strategic litigation has resulted in significant client settlements. 

Notably, Kigan secured the highest settlement in Southern Utah, a record-setting figure that underscores his prowess in the courtroom. His deep-rooted commitment to his clients and his skill in personal injury law have helped recover over $100 million in resolutions, affirming his position as a leader in Southern Utah’s legal landscape.
Schedule Your
Free Consultation
Fill out the form

"*" indicates required fields

Full Name*
Required Fields *
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
chevron-down